Btukfyl

International Skating Union International Skating Union Tipo Desportiva Fundação 1892 Sede Lausana Presidente Jan Dijkema Sítio oficial http://www.isu.org/

up vote 7 down vote favorite 3 This question already has an answer here: Should I respond to editors about unprofessional review? 1 answer My problem is similar to this this and this question, but still slightly different. I am facing the problem that my paper was rejected form a journal (with the option to resubmit to the same journal again), where two reviews were provided. The first review was well written, constructive and shows that the main parts of the paper were read and understood. Nevertheless, the first reviewer suggests to "Review Again After Major Changes". The second review (who rejected the paper) on the other hand shows clearly that he neither read the paper nor the references listed in the related